I have the mopar mats and I like them, they are a good price point for what you get, currently about $110 (they were $99 when I purchased them)
I like that they say "JEEP" on them and they look good, fit perfect and complement the rest of the vehicle.
Those rugged ridge ones look pretty good also.
The mopar ones are a tiny bit thinner than maybe I would like and slightly more plastic-like than rubber, sort of a cross between the two, but I've had them for over a year now and they have been excellent. You can read my review and see some pics I took in that amazon listing I linked above.
As far as coverage for the pedals go almost none of the commercially available options are going to be satisfactory there, because there is a major legal concern about any type of floor mat that could even potentially interfere with the brake or gas pedals. It sucks but its another result of sue-everyone-to-death-america.
84z28 mentioned how the rear mopar mats are not dished forward and that is true, they won't hold an inch of water or anything but there is at least a 1/4" wall at the end of them so your typical snow melt off some shoes won't be enough to overrun that edge, and then its easier to slid things under the front seats from the back (I have a small first aid case under the seat, for example).
In another thread we have also talked about how a little bit of water and crud can get around the locating pins in the mats of the mopar ones, that same issue probably applies to others as well, you can see the pics I took in that thread:
I don't see it as a major issue but this winter I may put a piece of black tape or something over the pin holes to reduce that issue. I used the mopar mats all of last winter and they cleaned up great in the spring with the pressure washer and the floor looks great underneath still, and we track a lot of snow into this buggy over the course of a Minnesota winter!
Dollar for dollar, the mopar ones are great value and functionality but I could see splurging on some thicker more rubbery ones if one sees fit. They all probably work pretty good and they all dodge around the pedals more or less for fear of legal ramifications so other than some minute differences here and there I really don't think you can go wrong with any of them.